Church of the Beheading of John the Baptist in Diakovo as a Prototype of Boris Godunov’s Holy of Holies

Keywords: the Church of the Beheading of John the Baptist in Diakovo, Solomon’s Temple, Holy of Holies, Moscow, Ivan IV, Boris Godunov, multi-altar churches, image of Jerusalem

Abstract

The Church of the Beheading of John the Baptist in Diakovo is a unique monument that has no analogues in Russian or in world architecture. It is a multi-pillared structure built just a few hundred meters from the Church of the Ascension in Kolomenskoye and in many details resembling Saint Basil’s Cathedral in Moscow but with a dome, not a tabernacle on its top. As a rule, researchers date it within the years of life of Ivan IV, relying on the dedication of the main altar. However, iconographic analysis of the composition including a square base and a centric volume of the upper tier allows to suggest that this composition was conceived as a replication of the forms of the Old Testament Solomon’s Temple and the fortress walls of Jerusalem as they were represented in the 15th and 16th centuries. This circumstance, as well as the fact of the similarity of the plastic solution of the walls to the way they were decorated at the turn of the 16th and the 17th centuries, suggests that this work is Godunov’s project or, more precisely, a full-scale model of the Holy of Holies building conceived by him in the Moscow Kremlin. Apparently, King Boris wanted to symbolically repeat the famous biblical episode when David – the founder of the dynasty and a great warrior – prepared everything for the construction of the First Temple, but, obeying the word of the prophet, left his son Solomon the opportunity to realize it. In this case, the explanation of the choice of location for such an unusual structure is obtained. It was this area where Godunov’s military talents were clearly manifested in 1591 – in the battles against the Crimean Khan Ğazı II Giray, who planned to attack Moscow.

Author Biography

S. Yu. Kavtaradze, National Research University “Higher School of Economics”

DOI: https://doi.org/10.34680/vistheo-2022-4-2-182-201

Sergey Yu. Kavtaradze
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”,
Moscow, Russia
skavtaradze@hse.ru
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7525-908X

Abstract
The Church of the Beheading of John the Baptist in Diakovo is a unique monument that has no analogues in Russian or in world architecture. It is a multi-pillared structure built just a few hundred meters from the Church of the Ascension in Kolomenskoye and in many details resembling Saint Basil’s Cathedral in Moscow but with a dome, not a tabernacle on its top. As a rule, researchers date it within the years of life of Ivan IV, relying on the dedication of the main altar. However, iconographic analysis of the composition including a square base and a centric volume of the upper tier allows to suggest that this composition was conceived as a replication of the forms of the Old Testament Solomon’s Temple and the fortress walls of Jerusalem as they were represented in the 15th and 16th centuries. This circumstance, as well as the fact of the similarity of the plastic solution of the walls to the way they were decorated at the turn of the 16th and the 17th centuries, suggests that this work is Godunov’s project or, more precisely, a full-scale model of the Holy of Holies building conceived by him in the Moscow Kremlin. Apparently, King Boris wanted to symbolically repeat the famous biblical episode when David – the founder of the dynasty and a great warrior – prepared everything for the construction of the First Temple, but, obeying the word of the prophet, left his son Solomon the opportunity to realize it. In this case, the explanation of the choice of location for such an unusual structure is obtained. It was this area where Godunov’s military talents were clearly manifested in 1591 – in the battles against the Crimean Khan Ğazı II Giray, who planned to attack Moscow.

Keywords: the Church of the Beheading of John the Baptist in Diakovo, Solomon’s Temple, Holy of Holies, Moscow, Ivan IV,
Boris Godunov, multi-altar churches, image of Jerusalem

References

Balfour 2012 – Balfour A. Solomon’s Temple: Myth, Conflict, and Faith. Wiley-Blackwell, 2012.

Batalov 1994 – Batalov A. L. The Holy Sepulcher in the Plan of Boris Godunov’s ‘Holy of Holies’. Jerusalem in Russian Culture. Moscow, 1994. Pp. 154–171. In Russian.

Batalov 1996 – Batalov A. L. Moscow Stone Architecture of the Late 16th Century: Problems of Artistic Thinking of the Era. Moscow, 1996. In Russian.

Batalov 1998 – Batalov A. L. On Dating the Church of the Beheading of John the Baptist in Diakovo. Russian Artistic Culture of the 15th – 17th Centuries. State Historical and Cultural Museum-Reserve “Moscow Kremlin”. Materials and Research. Is. 11. Moscow, 1998. Pp. 220–239. In Russian.

Batalov, Vyatchanina 1988 – Batalov A. L., Vyatchanina T. N. On the Ideological Significance and Interpretation of the Jerusalem Pattern in Russian Architecture of the 16th – 17th Centuries. Architectural Heritage. Is. 36. Moscow, 1988. Pp. 22–42. In Russian.

CCRC 1910 – Complete Collection of Russian Chronicles. Vol. 14.
St. Petersburg, 1910. In Russian.

CCRC 1978 – Complete Collection of Russian Chronicles. Vol. 34. Moscow, 1978. In Russian.

Derzhavina 1951 – The Ivan Timofeev’s Chronicle. Ed. by O. A. Derzhavina. Moscow, Leningrad, 1951. In Russian.

Derzhavina, Kolosova 1955 – The Tale of Avraamy Palitsyn. Ed. by O. A. Derzhavina, E. V. Kolosova. Moscow, Leningrad, 1955. In Russian.

Freiberg 2014 – Freiberg J. Bramante’s Tempietto, the Roman Renaissance, and the Spanish Crown. Cambridge University Press, 2014.

Ilyin 1980 – Ilyin M. A. Russian Tent Architecture. Monuments of the Middle of the 16th Century: Problems and Hypotheses, Ideas and Images. Moscow, 1980. In Russian.

Kavelmacher 1990 – Kavelmacher V. V. On the History of the Construction Birthday Church of Ivan the Terrible in the Village of Diakovo. Moscow, 1990. URL: http://www.rusarch.ru/kavelmakher15.htm. In Russian.

Kavtaradze 2019 – Kavtaradze S. Yu. “In the Image of the Holy Tabernacle”. A Probable Origin of the Russian Tent-like Churches. Space of the Icon. Iconography and Hierotopy. Moscow, 2019. Pp. 161–185. In Russian.

Konrad von Grünenberg 1487 – Beschreibung der Reise von Konstanz nach Jerusalem durch Konrad von Grünenberg, um 1487.
Cod. St. Peter. Pap. 32. URL: https://digital.blb-karlsruhe.de/blbhs/content/pageview/3853500 (accessed: 15.09.2022).

Martynov, Snegirev 1848 – Russian Antiquity in the Monuments of Sacred and Civil Architecture. Ed. by A. Martynov. Text by
I. M. Snegirev. Part 1. Moscow, 1848. In Russian.

Massa 1937 – Massa I. Brief News about Moscovia at the Beginning of the 17th Century. Transl. into Russian by A. A. Morozov. Moscow, 1937.

Massa, Herckmans 1874 – Tales of I. Massa and E. Herckmans about the Time of Troubles in Russia. Transl. into Russian. St. Petersburg, 1874.

Mintslov 1868 – Tales of Foreign Writers about Russia, Published by the Archaeographic Commission. Transl. into Russian. Vol. 2. Ed. by
R. Mintslov. St. Petersburg, 1868.

Moore 2017 – Moore K. B. The Architecture of the Christian Holy Land: Reception from Late Antiquity through the Renaissance. Cambridge University Press, 2017.

Podyapolsky 1983 – Podyapolsky S. S. Architect Petrok the Less. Monuments of Russian Architecture and Monumental Art. Style, Attribution, Dating. Moscow, 1983. Pp. 34–50. In Russian.

Richter 1850 – Monuments of Old Russian Architecture, Taken from Nature and Presented in Plans, Facades, Sections, with Wonderful Details of Stone Carvings and Paintings. Ed. by F. Richter. Moscow, 1850. In Russian.

Romanov 1925 – Romanov K. K. Pskov, Novgorod and Moscow in their Cultural and Artistic Relationships. News of the Russian Academy of the History of Material Culture. 1925. Vol. 4. Pp. 209–241. In Russian.

Worm 2011 – Worm A. Text – Bild – Kontext. Jerusalem in Hartmann Schedels Liber Chronicarum. Bild und Text im Mittelalter. Wien, Köln, Weimar, 2011. S. 175–203.

About author

Sergey Yu. Kavtaradze
Senior Lecturer of Art and Design School
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
11, Pokrovsky Boulevard, Moscow, 109028, Russian Federation
E-mail: skavtaradze@hse.ru

For citation:
Kavtaradze S. Yu. Church of the Beheading of John the Baptist in Diakovo as a prototype of Boris Godunov’s Holy of Holies. Journal of Visual Theology. 2022. Vol. 4. 2. Pp. 182–201.
https://doi.org/10.34680/vistheo-2022-4-2-182-201

Published
2022-12-26
Section
Articles
Views
355
Downloads
293