Eonotopos of Foolishness

Keywords: eonotopos, visionary, the fool for Christ’s sake, the icon of the fool, ‘pokhaby’, hierotopy, medieval city, thaumaturgy of the place

Abstract

The article is devoted to the relations between the urban blessed and the structure of the urban space. Walking on the streets of ancient Russian cities, making daily rounds of sacred places, wandering through especially significant places of the medieval polis, praying in temples and churches, serving prayers at natural shrines, creating obscene performances, playing the role of commoners in shops and of the rich in palaces, directing human pain into the channel of humility and calmness, – it was them, the fools for Christ’s sake, who were the tuning fork of conscience, the moral beacons of the common life of Orthodox Russia. Hagiographic literature and folk legends have preserved references to those places that the fools visited especially often, where they could live and pray, where significant meetings took place, where they prophesied and humbled themselves, where they rested. This topos has entered the body of the city and is designated in historical memory as sacred space containing a strong prayer component. Often, with the addition of the iconographic type of the holy fool, these architectural and landscape loci became symbols of the saint and accompanied his attribution. This problem is especially relevant for the formation of the iconographic canon of locally venerated fools. The author raises the question of recognizing individual urban spaces as eonotopos, a topographical icon of visionary art. Special attention is paid to the Novgorod saints who performed the deed of foolishness – Nikolai Kochanov, Theodore of Novgorod, Mikhail Klopsky, Arseny of Novgorod. The memory of sacred topos as places of eternity has been preserved in people’s memory to the present day and serves as the basis for the formation of local identity and its representation in iconography.

Author Biography

O. A. Tuminskaya , The State Russian Museum

DOI: https://doi.org/10.34680/vistheo-2022-4-1-99-110

Olga A. Tuminskaya
The State Russian Museum, St. Petersburg, Russia 
olgmorgun@yandex.ru
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0160-8299

Abstract
The article is devoted to the relations between the urban blessed and the structure of the urban space. Walking on the streets of ancient Russian cities, making daily rounds of sacred places, wandering through especially significant places of the medieval polis, praying in temples and churches, serving prayers at natural shrines, creating obscene performances, playing the role of commoners in shops and of the rich in palaces, directing human pain into the channel of humility and calmness, – it was them, the fools for Christ’s sake, who were the tuning fork of conscience, the moral beacons of the common life of Orthodox Russia. Hagiographic literature and folk legends have preserved references to those places that the fools visited especially often, where they could live and pray, where significant meetings took place, where they prophesied and humbled themselves, where they rested. This topos has entered the body of the city and is designated in historical memory as sacred space containing a strong prayer component. Often, with the addition of the iconographic type of the holy fool, these architectural and landscape loci became symbols of the saint and accompanied his attribution. This problem is especially relevant for the formation of the iconographic canon of locally venerated fools. The author raises the question of recognizing individual urban spaces as eonotopos, a topographical icon of visionary art. Special attention is paid to the Novgorod saints who performed the deed of foolishness – Nikolai Kochanov, Theodore of Novgorod, Mikhail Klopsky, Arseny of Novgorod. The memory of sacred topos as places of eternity has been preserved in people’s memory to the present day and serves as the basis for the formation of local identity and its representation in iconography.

Keywords: eonotopos, visionary, the fool for Christ’s sake, the icon of the fool, ‘pokhaby’, hierotopy, medieval city, thaumaturgy of the place

References

Biographies 1992 – Biographies of Saints of the Russian Church. Moscow, 1992. In Russian.

Bondarenko 2002 – Bondarenko I. A. Ancient Russian Urban Planning: Traditions and Ideals. Moscow, 2002. In Russian.

Dictionary 1991 – Historical Dictionary about Saints Glorified in the Russian Church, and about Some Ascetics of Piety, Locally Famous. Moscow, 1991. In Russian.

Fedotov 1994 – Fedotov G. P. On Holiness, Intelligentsia and Bolshevism: Selected Articles. St. Petersburg, 1994. In Russian.

Golubinsky 1881 – Golubinsky E. E. The History of the Canonization of Saints in the Russian Church. Moscow, 1881. In Russian.

Ivanov 1994 – Ivanov S. A. Byzantine Foolishness. Moscow, 1994.
In Russian.

Karger 1980 – Karger M. K. Novgorod. Leningrad, 1980. In Russian.

Kovalevsky 1991 – Kovalevsky I., priest. The Foolishness for Christ and Fools for Christ’s Sake of the Eastern and Russian Churches. Historical Essay and Lives of the Ascetics of Piety. Moscow, 1991.
In Russian.

Krasnyansky 1895 – Krasnyansky G. D. Brief Information in the Order of the Month about the Saints of God and the Miraculous Icons of Novgorod, Its Environs and the Entire Novgorod Diocese in General. Riga, 1895. In Russian.

Kushnir 1982 – Kushnir I. I. Architecture of Novgorod. Leningrad, 1982. In Russian.

Lebedev 1995 – Lebedev L., archpriest. Patriarchal Moscow. Moscow, 1995. In Russian.

Lepahin 2007 – Lepahin V. V. Iconology and Iconicity. Icon and Image, Iconicity and Literature. Moscow, 2007. Pp. 129–164. In Russian.

Lidov 2009 – Spatial Icons. Textuality and Performativity.
Ed. by A. M. Lidov. Moscow, 2009. In Russian.

Menaion 1996 – Menaion for Church Service. Moscow, 1996.
In Russian.

Nikolai Kochanov – The Life of the Holy Blessed Fool for Christ’s Sake Nikolai Kochanov, the Novgorod Wonderworker. Russian National Library. Tikhanov’s Collection. No. 728. 19th Century.
Sh. 2 (verso) – 6. In Russian.

Orlov 1965 – Orlov S. N. On the Topography of the Novgorod City Ends. Soviet Archaeology. 1965. No. 2. Pp. 92–103. In Russian.

Procopius 1893 – The Life of St. Procopius of Ustyug. St. Petersburg, 1893. In Russian.

Tereshkina 2021 – Tereshkina D. B. Novgorod Hagiographic Literature: Text and Image. Journal of Visual Theology. 2021. 1 (4). Pp. 85–104.
In Russian.

Tuminskaya 2012 – Tuminskaya O. A. The Novgorod Wackies in the Sacred Space of the City. Izvestia: Herzen University Journal of Humanities and Sciences. 2012. 146. Pp. 137–144. In Russian.

Vasilyev 1893 – Vasilyev V. The History of the Canonization of Russian Saints. Moscow, 1893. In Russian.

About author

Olga A. Tuminskaya
Dr. Sci. (Art History)
Section Head of Aesthetic Education, Methodological Department
The State Russian Museum
4, Inzhenernaya ul., St. Petersburg, 191186, Russian Federation
E-mail: olgmorgun@yandex.ru

For citation:
Tuminskaya O. A. Eonotopos of foolishness. Journal of Visual Theology. 2022. Vol. 4. 1. Pp. 99–110. https://doi.org/10.34680/vistheo-2022-4-1-99-110

Published
2022-06-29
Section
Articles
Views
236
Downloads
115