Iconography in Words: Constructing a Glossary of the Iconographic Method

Keywords: Christian iconography, iconographic method, miniaturist, sample, copying, iconographic program

Abstract

The article describes the experience of compiling and classifying an extensive, but poorly unified terminological base used by researchers in the field of iconography. We are not talking about terms used to put the content of images into words, but about key theoretical terms, such as “sample”, “model”, “original”, “copy”, “quote” and other similar concepts employed in iconographic thought. The paper discusses the usage of these terms by both classical and modern authors, such as N. V. Pokrovsky, A. Grabar, F. Bruno, G. Svartsensky, J. Alexander, etc. Further, we propose to arrange the concepts into four classes: (1) definitions referring to an entire image and its components; (2) definitions relating to the content of a single work or a cycle in their entirety or divided into units of meaning; (3) terminology around a “sample – copy – quote” type of relationship between individual images and the copying process itself; (4) the terms describing the visual toolkit of a particular master or a group and ways of its transmission both within and outside his workshop, including guides, manuals and instructions for craftsmen. In each class, the terms are listed in the order from basic and elementary to more complex and sophisticated. The classification is not complete and requires further work.

Author Biography

A. V. Pozhidaeva , National Research University “Higher School of Economics”

DOI: https://doi.org/10.34680/vistheo-2024-6-1-15-36

Anna V. Pozhidaeva
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”,
Moscow, Russia
apojidaeva69@mail.ru
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0247-933X

Nana А. Mkrtchian
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”,
Moscow, Russia
nana3101@yandex.ru
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0000-6059-4179

Maria K. Sidorenko
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”,
Moscow, Russia
mksidorenko@edu.hse.ru
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0007-8819-9657

Sofia V. Spiridonova
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”,
Moscow, Russia
svspiridonova@edu.hse.ru
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0003-5062-3185

Evgenia А. Suslova
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”,
Moscow, Russia
easuslova_1@edu.hse.ru
ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0009-0138-4222

Abstract
The article describes the experience of compiling and classifying
an extensive, but poorly unified terminological base used by researchers in the field of iconography. We are not talking about terms used to put the content of images into words, but about key theoretical terms, such as “sample”, “model”, “original”, “copy”, “quote” and other similar concepts employed in iconographic thought. The paper discusses the usage of these terms by both classical and modern authors, such as N. V. Pokrovsky, A. Grabar,
F. Bruno, G. Svartsensky, J. Alexander, etc. Further, we propose
to arrange the concepts into four classes: (1) definitions referring to an entire image and its components; (2) definitions relating to
the content of a single work or a cycle in their entirety or divided into units of meaning; (3) terminology around a “sample – copy – quote” type of relationship between individual images and the copying process itself; (4) the terms describing the visual toolkit of
a particular master or a group and ways of its transmission both within and outside his workshop, including guides, manuals and instructions for craftsmen. In each class, the terms are listed in
the order from basic and elementary to more complex and sophisticated. The classification is not complete and requires further work.

Keywords: Christian iconography, iconographic method, miniaturist, sample, copying, iconographic program

References

Abramovich 1931 – Abramovich D. The Kyiv Caves Patericon. Kyiv, 1931. In Ukrainian.

Alexander 1992 – Alexander J. J. G. Medieval Illuminators and
Their Methods of Works. Yale, 1992.

Battini et al. 2006 – Battini M., Saladino V., Franzoni C., Settis S. Schemata: comunicazione non verbale nella Grecia Antica.
Quaderni Storici. 2006. Vol. 41. 123 (3). Pp. 671–701.

Borlée, Terrier Aliferis 2018 – Les modèles dans l’art du Moyen Age (XII–XV siècles). Ed. by D. Borlée, L. Terrier Aliferis. Turnhout, 2018.

Bruneau 1984 – Bruneau P. Les mosaïstes antiques avaient–ils des Cahiers de modèles? Revue Archéologique. 1984. 2. Pp. 241–272.

Cаillet 2012 – Cаillet J. P. La mise à profit de manuscrits antérieurs en tant que modèles par les miniaturistes du VIIIe au XIIe siècle. Cаhiers de Saint-Michel de Cuxa. 2012. 43. Pp. 49–60.

Carruthers 2008 – Carruthers M. The Book of Memory: A Study of Memory in Medieval Culture. Cambridge, 2008.

Demus 1949 – Demus O. The Mosaics of Norman Sicily. London, 1949.

Demus 1970 – Demus O. Byzantine Art and the West. New York, 1970.

Dmitriev, Olshevskaya 1997 – The Kyiv Caves Patericon. Ed. by L. A. Dmitriev, L. A. Olshevskaya. Library of Ancient Russia Literature. Vol. 4. St. Peterburg, 1997. Pp. 296–489. In Russian.

Grabar 1968 – Grabar A. Christian Iconography: A Study of Its Origins. Princeton, 1968.

Kessler 1971 – Kessler H. L. Hic Homo Formatur: The Genesis Frontispieces of the Carolingian Bibles. Art Bulletin. 1971. 53.
Pp. 143–160.

Kessler 1977 – Kessler H. L. The Illustrated Bibles from Tours. Princeton, 1977.

Kitzinger 1960 a – Kitzinger E. The Mosaics of Monreale. Palermo, 1960.

Kitzinger 1960 b – Kitzinger E. I mosaici di Monreale. Trad. di Fanny Bonajuto. Palermo, 1960.

Martin 1904 – Martin H. Les esquisses des miniatures.
Revue Archéologique. 1904. 4. Pp. 17–45.

Müller 2014 – Müller M. E. Introduction. The Use of Models in Medieval Book Painting. Cambridge, 2014. Pp. xi–xviii.

Panofsky 2009 – Panofsky E. Studies in Iconology: Humanistic Themes in the Art of the Renaissance. Transl. into Russian by N. G. Lebedeva, N. A. Osminskaya. Moscow, 2009.

Pokrovsky 1900 – Pokrovsky N. V. Essays on Monuments of Christian Art. St. Peterburg, 1900. In Russian.

Pozhidaeva 2021 – Pozhidaeva A. V. The Creation of the World
in the Iconography of the Medieval West. Moscow, 2021. In Russian.

Scheller 1995 – Scheller R. W. Exemplum Model-Book Drawings and the Practice of Artistic Transmission in the Middle Ages
(ca. 900 – ca. 1470). Amsterdam, 1995.

Settis 2013 – Settis S. La «Tempesta» interpretata. Torino, 2013.

Stones 1990 – Stones A. Indications ecrites et modeles picturaux, guides aux peintres de manuscrits enlumines aux environs de 1300. Artistes, arttisans et production artistique au Moyen Age. 3. Fabrication et consommation de l’oeuvre. Paris, 1990. Pp. 321–349.

Swarzenski 1963 – Swarzenski H. The Role of Copies in the Formation of the Styles of the Eleventh Century. Studies in Western Art. Vol. 1: Romanesque and Gothic Art. Princeton, 1963. Pp. 7–18.

Verkerk 2004 – Verkerk D. Early Medieval Bible Illumination and the Ashburnham Pentateuch. Cambridge, 2004.

Weitzmann, Bernabò 1999 – Weitzmann K., Bernabò M. The Byzantine Octateuchs. Princeton, 1999.

About authors

Anna V. Pozhidaeva
Cand. Sci. (Art History),
Associate Professor of Faculty of Humanities
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
1 Bldg., 21/4, Staraya Basmannaya St., Moscow, 105066,
Russian Federation
E-mail: apojidaeva69@mail.ru

Nana А. Mkrtchian
Master’s student of “Medieval Studies” Programme
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
1 Bldg., 21/4, Staraya Basmannaya St., Moscow, 105066,
Russian Federation
E-mail: nana3101@yandex.ru

Maria K. Sidorenko
Bachelor’s student of “History of Art” Programme
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
1 Bldg., 21/4, Staraya Basmannaya St., Moscow, 105066,
Russian Federation
E-mail: mksidorenko@edu.hse.ru

Sofia V. Spiridonova
Bachelor’s student of “History of Art” Programme
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
1 Bldg., 21/4, Staraya Basmannaya St., Moscow, 105066,
Russian Federation
E-mail: svspiridonova@edu.hse.ru

Evgenia А. Suslova
Bachelor’s student of “History of Art” Programme
National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
1 Bldg., 21/4, Staraya Basmannaya St., Moscow, 105066,
Russian Federation
E-mail: easuslova_1@edu.hse.ru

For citation:
Pozhidaeva A. V., Mkrtchian N. А., Sidorenko M. K., Spiridonova S. V., Suslova E. А. Iconography in words: Constructing a glossary of
the iconographic method. Journal of Visual Theology. 2024. Vol. 6. 1.
Pp. 15–36. https://doi.org/10.34680/vistheo-2024-6-1-15-36

Published
2024-06-26
Section
Articles
Views
484
Downloads
147